It’s kind of surprising how much crap you’ll find if you browse online for first birthday party supplies. So we were totally floored to discover Gaddie and Tood’s old school handmade party hats ($16.50)—brilliant for photo ops, and totally worthy of nursery shelf display, after the party. We’re also suckers for SewBarefoot’s natural burlap birthday banners ($17.95), Lil Threadz’ organic blend patchwork “ONE” tees, and the ready-made fondant number cupcake toppers from Edible Details ($21 for 12). And when it comes to choosing a party theme, the best place to steal ideas is Just sayin’.